The Scribby thing I find is rather 'flat' compared to the more relaxed and natural talk between the Awesome 4.. but some of essays are quite interesting and funny. Annoying thing, can never find the website where these essays are suppose to be posted.

Maybe I just can't spell scribulus.

One thing that would be nice...when webpages are talked about in each pottercast, is they are also listed in the summary as well...even if its at the bottom after all the 'topics'. Be very useful for listeners I think....especially considering many listeners don't listen where they have pen and paper handy to write down webpages and such and trying to scan through a podcast to find where a webpage is mentioned...can be tricky

Lexi, I think the Scribby 5 debate is important because us PC Listeners all want to enjoy the segment, and as a fan community we're putting our heads together on ways the segment can be improved! That's all!

I am going to Terminus. I had so much fun with you guys at Phoenix Rising. Can we play the trivia dueling game again? I did so well on that at Phoenix Rising. :)

Can we please move on from the Scribby 5 topic? If you don't like it fastforward, that's perfectly acceptable and what I do.

i agree 100% with Ian. throw out the script and start a new. I'm sure you put lots of effort into the script every week, but no matter how good the script itself is, reading will always sound...Scripted! however i appreciate that you must put a lot of work into it though.

Naeomi

Ya, Scribbby5 has potential to be awesome. Why not get the author of the essay on, and then a fan who opposes the idea of the essay, and stir up a debate? It'd be interesting, and unscripted.

I have to agree with 'Nagini in a Bubble'. When I first heard it i was walking down the street and started to crack up....embarassing; hope too many people werent looking! :P

I have to say...Scribby 5 has always had potential, but it's never really matched up. I would say either cancel Scribby 5 (it kind of spoils the essays for me when I listen, anyway) or change it...alot.

My thoughts on Scribby 5: It needs improvement, but not a total change. I certainly don't want it canceled, but revamped a little. NO SCRIPT, please. You could write down points to talk about so that you don't forget what to say, but also keep it light and less scripted. Because really, at this point, everyone who I talk to skips Scribby 5.

Great show as usual people! I'm glad I'm not alone on the issue of Scribby 5. It's just that, it gets a bit boring and so,I skip ahead.

And also, I was wondering what happened to bit-by-bit! Now that Phoenix Files is over, could we have bit-by-bit again? And I miss Canon Conundrums too! I loved those segments!

Anyhow, you guys ROCK!! Love PotterCast!

Oh, and "Nagini in a Bubble"...LOVE IT!!! Frak...we need a drawing!!!

Like 'Nagini in a bubble!!!' Brazilliant!!!!
John Noe, i have a total crush on you just for that :D

FRAK, please please please please please sketch Nagini in a bubble/aguilera style! :D